News & Insights5 sections3 min read

Hiring Managers Are Rejecting AI Resumes at Record Rates

September 30, 2026 3 min read
Hiring Managers Are Rejecting AI Resumes at Record Rates

Whitney Ortiz, certified professional and executive resume writer and DoD training and development manager at Recruit Military, joined MyComputerCareer’s Get Into IT Live to tackle a question most job seekers hate asking: why am I not getting the job?

For a growing number of candidates, the answer starts with how they build their resume.

01 / 05The AI Resume Problem

According to multiple sources Whitney cited, hiring managers are rejecting AI-generated resumes at rates between 57 and 80%.

“The AI resume says a lot of stuff, but it’s not saying anything at all,” Whitney said. “It might look good, but it doesn’t make sense to the reader.”

The tells are easy to spot if you know where to look. Em dashes, blue text labels, a dump of 50 categorized skills at the top, and paragraphs that sound impressive but don’t say anything specific. Hiring managers see these patterns daily and move on fast.

Put it into practice

Pick the program that teaches these skills.

Every program is certification-based and taught live by instructors.

02 / 05Use AI as a Springboard, Not a Ghostwriter

Whitney isn’t anti-AI. She recommends using it to brainstorm, test different ways of wording your experience, or restructure a resume for a career change. The key is treating it as a starting point, not a finished product.

“We still need to go in and make sure it’s in our voice,” she said. “If we’re sitting in an interview and you don’t sound like your resume, that’s a red flag.”

She also suggested flipping the script. Prompt AI to act as a hiring manager. Give it your resume and the job description and ask what stands out, what’s missing, and what raises concerns. Her words: “Game the system.”

03 / 05The Page Fold Test

For career changers (a big chunk of MyComputerCareer’s student body), Whitney shared a dead-simple gut check. Print your resume, fold it in half hamburger-style, and look at the top section. Does that half of page one clearly communicate your value for the role you’re targeting?

If your certifications, technical skills, and strongest qualifications live on page two, that’s likely why you’re not hearing back. Pull them up on the doc.

Whitney also recommended the combination resume (sometimes called a skills-based resume) for anyone whose job titles don’t translate to a new field. Lead with skill categories and supporting examples instead of a chronological job history.

Talk to an Enrollment Advisor

Programs, cost, funding and start dates, in one conversation. No obligation.

Request Information

04 / 05Networking Still Wins

Even with AI running both sides of the hiring process, Whitney kept driving one point home: human connection.

“I might see 500 resumes a year, but if I’ve talked to a person about their resume, I’m going to remember them,” she said. “A conversation changes everything.”

Her advice: get to career fairs, connect on LinkedIn, stop being a stranger. Name recognition can be the reason your resume gets a second look when AI filters miss you.

05 / 05One Thing to Do Today

Whitney’s final takeaway was simple. Know your target. Think about a dartboard with a single bullseye. Your resume, your LinkedIn, your interview prep should all aim at the same spot. If you’re applying to different types of roles, build separate versions. Don’t try to make one document accomplish everything.

Watch the full Get Into IT Live conversation with Whitney below.

Watch the video on YouTube

Ready to earn the certifications that make your resume stand out? Learn more about our programs.

FAQ

Questions about this story

Whitney Ortiz cited sources saying hiring managers reject AI-generated resumes at rates between 57 and 80%. She says these resumes can look good but say nothing specific, and hiring managers spot the patterns quickly and move on.
Whitney recommends using AI to brainstorm, test different wording or restructure a resume for a career change, then rewriting it in your own voice. She also suggests prompting AI to act as a hiring manager and review your resume against the job description.
Print your resume, fold it in half, and check whether the top half of page one clearly shows your value for the role you want. If your certifications and strongest qualifications are on page two, that may be why you are not hearing back.
ME

Written by

MyComputerCareer Editorial Team

Career Education, Certifications & IT Workforce Research

Our editorial team partners with enrollment advisors, certification instructors, and industry employers to publish guidance grounded in real hiring data. Every article is reviewed for accuracy against current BLS labor statistics, vendor certification roadmaps, and the latest DoD Directive 8140 requirements.

Start Your Career Journey Now!

Talk to an Enrollment Advisor